Victrix Computational Chemistry and Medicinal Chemistry Consultancy
Contact us
  • Home
  • Philosophy
  • Services
  • Our Clients
  • Contact
  • About
    • Press Releases
  • Victrix Sounds Off
  • Blog

Are all dietary calories created equal, or Sugar: threat or menace

7/1/2013

1 Comment

 
Picture
Robert Lustig was talking at the Aspen Ideas Conference last week. He has been on a crusade against fructose for some time.  He is one of the leading proponents that all calories are not created equal. He claims that sugar is one of the most toxic substances we can consume and wants it regulated like alcohol.  I tend to react poorly to alarmist phraseology.  I do not believe that  sugar causes cancer any more than I think that police cause highway accidents.  The is a clear confusion of correlation (some cancer cells selectively metabolize sugars, you always see a police car at an accident scene) with cause.  

However there is a significant amount of truth that humans were opportunistic omnivores.  We ate meat, vegetables, nuts, berries, but no significant amounts of grain.  we got fructose in our diet from fruit, but it wasn't constant and it was most likely an episodic binge.  When we learned agriculture, our life spans, cranial capacities and overall measures of health decreased. The source of this information is the very fascinating book: "Paleopathology at the Origins of Agriculture (Bioarchaeological Interpretations of the Human Past: Local, Regional, and Global)" it's recommended reading. 

Clearly we didn't evolve to eat so much grain. A more reasoned approach to the problem can be found in the work of Dr. Peter Attia, who was an obese and pre-diabetic surgeon turned nutrition researcher who, I think quite rightly shows that people confuse acute with chronic toxicity.  He explains the issue quite well here. 

Personally I was a vegan (for moral, not health reasons) and was very obese.  I have lost 65 pounds consuming more calories than I ate before on a slow carb diet.  I'm still losing, but now I'm just fat, not obese. I resumed eating meat (grass fed, organic and also game meat.  (tip: wild boar makes a great burger)) and all of my blood markers are better than they were whilst vegan.  You can chalk that up to anecdotal evidence.  But I do believe all calories are not equal. 

Stay healthy out there. Take what I say with a grain of salt, but do look into the concept of caloric difference.

1 Comment
Clara Marsden
7/1/2013 02:35:58 pm

I believe that genetically modified food has many consequences that we are not even aware of.... And that might be the reason why even as a vegetarian you were obese. Good read on this issue: "wheat belly by William Davis MD"

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Adam Kallel Ph. D.

    Our CSO sounds off about drug discovery, computational chemistry and history

    Archives

    March 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013

    Categories

    All
    Ageing
    Amphetamine
    Anti-virals
    Biography
    Broken Society
    Caffeine
    Cancer
    Cd26
    Cluster Headache
    Colic
    Collaboration
    Corona Virus
    Danger Danger
    Depression
    Drug Discovery
    Drug Resistence
    Economy Of Scale
    Electron Microscopy
    Emergent Infectious Disease
    Encephalitis Lethargica
    Global Epidemiology
    Goal Setting
    HCoV-EMC
    Hiring
    Incorrect Pathologizing
    Incretin
    Influenza
    Jobs
    Me
    Merck
    Mergers
    Metabolic Disease
    Migraine
    Nerd
    Neurotransmiters
    Open Positions
    Over Prescription
    Overwork
    Pharma
    Pharmaceutical Industry
    Restructuring
    Stimulants
    Telomerase
    Tuberculosis
    Viral Replication
    Virus

    RSS Feed

    comments powered by Disqus
    View my profile on LinkedIn